Did George Really Sing Fool on the Hill?

[DarkHorse]

redlion said:

doctorrobert said:

Hey, every musician in America, if they know the Beatles and Sgt. Pepper, knows that that is Ringo singing WALHFMF.

Don't take my word for it, take a poll.


You don't need a machine. You don't need a spectrographic read-out.

Perfectly agreed 1000% Ringo.

To continue the discussion on Ringo, please go to: invanddis.proboards29.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=general&thread=1133910269

[TotalInformation]

1000%

This is exactly the problem, the certainty.

This song is the one most people think of first when they think of Ringo's voice. It's 'his' song on the most highly-regarded and popular album. It *is* the baseline, so...

I just watched a new Ringo concert and a new FAUL concert. Ringo's vocal on this song sounded least like the album vocals on either show. (Comparing FAUL/FAUL and Ringo/'Ringo' not FAUL/JPM).

[Red Lion]

totalinformation said:

This is exactly the problem, the certainty.

It's really no problem at all, Paul was replaced not Ringo.

[TotalInformation]

Paul was replaced not Ringo.

Totally beside the point.

[Red Lion]

totalinformation said:

Totally beside the point.

Actually it is not, Ringo didnt need a vocal imitator.

[TotalInformation]

It's not a question of necessity.