Birthday Date of birth

[timemuddies]

Everywhere you look has a certain date of birth listed for McCartney.

The thing is it only takes one deceit for the misinformation to spread...

So what is his date of birth?

If you thought it was 18 June 1942 I don't blame you as everywhere online would have you believe that.
Everywhere apart from the most reliable resource that exists!

I don't know why they thought it wise to alter the date but it was a mistake and quite the clue...

In the UK, records do exist for births marriages and deaths. The government publishes for all to look at online...

What happens if you look up McCartney?
Well if you look up Paul McCartney you end up at the wrong place!

Try looking up
James P. McCartney

now try filtering the search for the 10 years +- 1940

It gives a few as it's a UK wide search.
(We could use the district filter if needed to choose Lancashire as Liverpool was part of that district back in the 40s-60s)

        Surname Given Name Mother District Volume Page
        Births Sep 1942
        McCartney James P. Mahon Liverpool N. 8b 604

Hey we get a result for Liverpool!
The odd thing isn't the result.
Look at the month...

www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?r=184673566:4048&d=bmd_1477344112

A different person maybe right?

Look at the mothers maiden name!

So, we just found McCartney's real, correct date of birth.

But everywhere else has June listed, how can this be?

If I was a cynic I would say someone was trying to hide something but I'm not cynical, I'm just researching.


Ok so in closing.... big deal someone got the month wrong and the misinformation spread.

But how did it change and why?

I bet reading this some of you are thinking "Well that must be Williams birth month and he wouldnt change that would he?!"

And lets find out...

So far people have said PID and was replaced by someone.
It is said that the person is William Shears Campbell.
It is also said that William was a few (up to 5) years older than McCartney.
It is also said that the person writing for the beatle magazine was called Bill(y) Shepherd
It is also said William can be shortened to a name starting with B
It also said this person just vanished from any noted info during 66 sometime.

So lets run with this crazy, cynical idea of the conspiracy theory and prove it wrong.


Off we go to the UK bmd archive and search for any William Campbell born +-10 years around 1940...



    This entry was created from the following transcription:

    Surname Given Name Mother District Volume Page
    Births Jun 1938
    Campbell William S. McGrecoy Liverpool S. 8b 256

Oh dear, you can't disprove the theory as trying to just leads to more reasonable doubt that PIA

See for yourselves...

www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?r=175958957:5385&d=bmd_1477344112

So if this is the identity of the replacement, maybe it is worth researching the family details discovered above...

Mother
McGrecoy

[B]

What am I missing?
When I click on the links, I find the month of your search, but I don't see a date of birth.

Please point out where it is for us.

[timemuddies]

Nov 18, 2016 12:40:36 GMT -5 B said:

What am I missing?
When I click on the links, I find the month of your search, but I don't see a date of birth.

Please point out where it is for us.

For James P. the date is above the full name, but it only shows month, year.

For William S. the layout and amount of info held is also following the above convention(s).

Reread my main post above in its entirity and look carefully at the info I found which I included in the post.

I also provided the direct source links and steps for manually doing the search so you can verify the findings yourself.

I couldn't have made it any clearer without an image but then it cant be verified easily. Whereas my steps for searching can reproduce the finding if anyone doubts the info.

[applepie]

Why would somebody - in a higher position of power - wish to alter Macca's original date of birth? I couldn't possibly see this benefitting anyone, but just being a mere waste of time, but who knows? Maybe there is a reason behind this alleged fabrication of McCartney's date of birth, but I just can't see it as of know. Perhaps I need to look through the looking glass! There's twists and turns as we lurk deeper into this perceived 'rabbit-hole.' Don't take a clue for granted.

[applepie]

Double post. Whoopsies

[beatlas231]

I don't get what it is I'm looking for... can someone explain why the title isn't complete bullocks so then maybe I can indulge in reading some of this...


I'll tell you where you WOULDNT find his birthdate information

definitely not Photobucket...

Close.....

If you really want to open the layer to see through the glass onion


Here's another clue for you all


Fixing a hole in the Monith of Phobos

Written by someone who's old enough to be me Father, but he calls me Daddy.

Hold the sugar, LOVELYRITA ;-)

Maybe when you make a pot of tea, you can chip some ice from your heart to cool it down for me old lips to put my tongue against

If I smell what you're cooking ;-)

[applepie]

Here's what I CAN say. The Beatles were most definitely "ahead of their times." To elaborate further on such a seemingly vague comment, allow your mind to process this entire 'Paul is Dead' folklore/myth as being more of a 'message' that was meant to be discovered and interpreted by future generations, than what was actually occurring in that time-frame.

[applepie]

I must leave you all with these photographs. 

[Deleted]

it's an invitation

m.youtube.com/watch?v=XXxVwpcXV0U

lol

[applepie]

Nov 20, 2016 2:18:35 GMT -5 michelle said:

Nov 19, 2016 22:51:00 GMT -5 applepie said:

I must leave you all with these photographs. 


View AttachmentView Attachment

5 Beatles? Is this JPM dressed up as Yoko?

These clues are intertwined. Read the lyrics

[beatlas231]

Nov 20, 2016 10:19:33 GMT -5 IWILL said:

it's an invitation

m.youtube.com/watch?v=XXxVwpcXV0U

lol

Satisfaction GAUREN-THREED!

[beatlas231]

Nov 20, 2016 2:18:35 GMT -5 michelle said:

Nov 19, 2016 22:51:00 GMT -5 applepie said:

I must leave you all with these photographs. 


View AttachmentView Attachment

5 Beatles? Is this JPM dressed up as Yoko?

Last night the Wife said


Oh boyyyyy

When yer dead

You don't take MUFFIN WITCHO SOUL, BOY!

So I ate it

[cyndaquilfire35]

Actually, that record covers July-September of 1942.

So the likely explanation is it just took a couple of weeks to have his birth officially registered. Remember, this lists when the birth was REGISTERED, not the date of the birth itself. Simple human error is another likely explanation. They also got his mother's maiden name wrong. It's not Mahon, it's Mohan (or Mohin, according to some sources).
But yeah, his birth certificate itself says Eighteenth of June.


As for William (S.) Campbell, I'm sure it's just a coincidence. It doesn't seem to be a terribly uncommon name by the looks of it. Also, the supposed Willam Shears Campbell character that replaced Paul never even existed.

"I made the guy up. It was originally going to be 'Glenn Campbell,' with two Ns and then I said 'that's too close, nobody'll buy that,' so I made it William Campbell."
--Fred LaBour, one of the main authors of the original PID theory

Also, doesn't the story go that Campbell was a Scottish orphan?